- HR Brain Pickings
- Posts
- Performance Improvement Plans 101
Performance Improvement Plans 101
Happy Monday! 😊
Hi everyone! This is Mariam Mushtaq from HR Brain Pickings - bringing to you this week’s first edition. ☝️ Hope you all got the chance to rest and recharge this weekend. 🧘
Ever had a team lead or manager on your doorstep, ready to fire someone for underperforming? While that might seem like the straightforward path, it doesn't have to be the only option. ✋

Performance Improvement Plans (PIPs) offer us an opportunity to shift gears - from the verge of saying goodbye to actively reinvesting in employee growth. 🌟
Do you think employees perceive PIPs as just a delayed firing call in your workplace? |
According to Gartner, a performance improvement plan (PIP) is a document that aims to help employees who are not meeting job performance goals.
A PIP identifies performance deficiencies, skills or training gaps, sets clear conduct expectations for an employee, with non-compliance possibly leading to termination. 💼
Understanding your role in PIPs as an HR 🤝
Let's take a moment to pinpoint exactly where HR fits into the Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) strategy, considering it's a collaborative effort alongside managers. 👥
Here's where HR’s role lies:
Determining if a PIP is really the best move for the current scenario. 🤔
Teaming up closely with managers throughout the PIP journey to ensure fairness and eliminate any bias. 🕵️♂️
Offering consistent support and expert advice to both the manager and the employee from start to finish. 🆘
FYI:
A progressive discipline policy often has 4 - 5 steps:
1. Coaching and re-establishing expectations.
2. Verbal reprimand.
3. Written reprimand.
4. Suspension, which is not always appropriate.
5. Termination.
* A PIP is part of the Written Reprimand phase. 📝
Note: If the performance failure is a one-time event, it may be too soon to implement a PIP.
How can we determine if PIP is the right move? 🤔
Getting the timing right for a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) is key in helping employees bounce back with a bit of guidance. ⏰
If you roll them out at the wrong time or in the wrong way, it can backfire, leading to stress, disengagement, or even legal headaches. 😟🚫That's why nailing the timing and approach is crucial.
Despite some raised eyebrows about PIPs, they do come with perks like clarifying expectations and fostering growth for employees. 🌱
Here are a couple of pointers to understand when to implement vs when to avoid a PIP. 👇

The next time a performance hiccup has you reaching for the PIP template, take a moment. 🤚 Keep in mind that PIPs can be about uncovering potential, fostering resilience, and, ultimately, winning together. 💪
Easing PIP Anxiety
Let's face it, the mere mention of a "PIP" often sparks fear and dread 😨 in employees. It's crucial to shift this perception: though it may initially sound alarm bells, 🔔 a PIP should be viewed as a chance for a remarkable turnaround.
It's a chance to turn an exit into a success story. How do we do this? By crafting a clear, attainable plan that's more positive, encouraging and supporting. 👍
Here are a few tips to reassure employees their job isn't on the line when PIPs start rolling out:
Company-Wide Announcement: A leader's message can significantly reduce employee anxiety, clarifying that PIPs in your organization aim for growth, not termination. 📣
Start Positive: Kick off discussions by acknowledging the employee's strengths. This positive approach fosters a constructive atmosphere, smoothly leading into areas for improvement. 😊
Be Clear About Objectives: Ensure the objectives within the PIP are unambiguous and within reach. Clear, achievable goals are essential as uncertainty can fuel anxiety. 🎯
Emphasize Support: Highlight that a PIP's goal is to offer support, not to penalize. Illustrate this by pointing to the resources and help available, demonstrating the company's commitment to their success. 🤝
Set Regular Check-ins: Commit to regular meetings to review progress as well as provide positive reinforcement. 📅
Highlight Success Stories: Sharing anonymized success stories of employees who've thrived post-PIP serves as a powerful motivator. 💪
Integrating these strategies into your discussions around PIPs can help in shifting the perception of PIPs to instruments of growth. 🛠️
In the upcoming issues - we take a deeper dive and explore how to create a performance improvement plan with examples. 🔍
Let's Hear From You: HR Voices | Real Stories, Real Insights We're curious: Do you have a PIP success story? Was there an employee who thrived post PIP? Share your strategies or stories with us. |
10-Minute Watch 📺
Employee Performance Improvement Plan (PIP): The What, Why and How
If you're an HR Manager looking to master PIPs, explore this playlist filled with expert insights, practical advice, and real-world case studies on all things Performance Improvement Plans (PIPs).
A Simple Solution for Virtual Team Bonding 🤝
Inject some fun into the workday with a swift 5-minute game break directly via Slack or MS Teams. Choose from engaging games like Instant Quizzes, Pictionary, Emoji Rebus, and more! 🎮
Break the monotony and introduce Trivia to your workspace. 🧩
Bonus Resource 🎁
This document offers prompts for custom training plans, course content, analyzing training needs, etc. 📚 It serves as a resource for designing effective L &D training programs that can be applied from onboarding new hires to supporting ongoing professional growth. 💼
What’s going on at The Shape of Work? 🌟
Here's a list of all the upcoming TSOW Community Calls:
1️⃣ March 19th: Navigating Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Belonging: Insights from Sodexo
2️⃣ March 20th: Charting Success: A 15-Year Journey in HR Leadership
3️⃣ March 21st: Startup HR Roadmap: Building Policy Frameworks from Scratch
Sign up and register for our exciting lineup of events 🎉, all free for you as a TSOW member!
Today’s Reads
Recent SHRM report reveals “Over 70% of HR professionals agree that women face discrimination in the labor market”. 📊 Read all the other key findings here.
Ever heard of “benefits envy”? Apparently, a survey found that 59% of U.S. workers said they have “benefits envy” of friends’ and family members’ coverage! 😲 Find out what magic trifecta is for employee benefits. Read the full article.
We’ve been through fully in-person meetings and fully-virtual meetings as well. How are you navigating those tricky hybrid meetings? 🤔 EBN shares 3 tools that might help.
Did you enjoy today's issue? |
Missed the last newsletter? Catch up here.
Reply